Lech Lecha: The Little Death of the Self
The Hidden Cost of Conformity
We don't go on adventures anymore. We don't walk into the great unknown. I don't go. It's not the accepted path.
There is safety in community. Until there isn't.
There is a world of adventure brimming inside me, a little voice that tries to remind me who I really am, but I have taught myself to quiet that voice within. To keep my little bluebird in its cage.
I sit beside this bluebird that lives in me. I watch him in his cage. And then I leave him there.
When I want to write a novel or poetry or start an organization to help young men, why do I feel the pressure to stay down, stay in the shadows, and not make waves?
Nimrod ruled with fear. He ruled with conformity. That was how the Tower of Bavel got built. Brick by brick. Same size, same shape, and the same weight. The directive might as well have been, "We will attack God in His place with this tower and with our conformity." Our conformity will amalgamate into a greater entity than even God Himself."
Truly, an insidious form of avodah zarah.
Why then does the Torah emphasize the one language and the fact that they made bricks in place of stone? I think there is a certain yetzer hara at work here. A yetzer for conformity. A place where megalomaniacs can take power and the meek can find somewhere safe to hide. Where growth never truly blooms except to strengthen the borders of the accepted space.
That was the world Avram lived in. And oftentimes, I feel like it's the world I live in. It's not the kind of world built for a Yid.
I see something of that conformity today. There is the accepted way, and then there are the myriad unaccepted ways. Fit in or die seems the appropriate motto. Any deviation from the preset arrangement is met with fear, masked in derision and exclusion.
Don't talk that way, because... shidduchim. These are the yeshivos you should attend, not those. These are the respectable professions for a frum Yid, not those. And artistic expression? Well, music is acceptable... mostly.
In an era of such abundance, why is it so?
And what of the young ones, told there are only two tracks for a Yid today? Why is that? I believe wholeheartedly that every child knows, deep down, what they want to do with their life. But adults spend the years between childhood and adulthood talking them out of it.
Because it's dangerous.
It's dangerous to deviate.
And the capital-C Community, whatever that means, is not completely wrong. There is safety in numbers. There is stability when each brick is made the same size, the same shape, and the same weight.
But something dies in the dying of the light. And I can rage, rage against the dying of the light, but the path is set, the coordinates entered into the GPS, and there is no deviation. No patient voice that says, "Recalculating..."
Maybe it’s not fair for me to judge. There is so much good. So much stability. So much infrastructure. It is so easy to be a Yid today, yet for some reason, it's so much harder.
I know the counterargument. This is not the first time I've brought this up, and the backlash always raises legitimate concerns. Things have never been better. Jews have rarely experienced such safety. Access to Torah and Jewish life has never been so accessible. Why rock the boat? What's your problem?
So we need to discover what it is about conformity that can become so destructive. I believe it carries within itself a flaw capable of destroying the whole more completely than any external force could.
The people were terrified of being scattered. They all moved together to the Valley of Shinar. They built a tower to overpower God Himself. Out of fear.
And Avram? He was told to go. With no directions. To walk away from everything familiar.
He was told:
לֶךְ־לְךָ מֵאַרְצְךָ וּמִמּוֹלַדְתְּךָ וּמִבֵּית אָבִיךָ אֶל־הָאָרֶץ אֲשֶׁר אַרְאֶךָ
"Go forth from your land, your birthplace, and your father's house, to the land that I will show you."
And Rashi famously comments:
לֶךְ לְךָ — לַהֲנָאָתְךָ וּלְטוֹבָתְךָ
"Go for your benefit and for your good."
Going out into the wild blue yonder was good for Avraham. And I believe there is a directive here for all Yidden as well. Go out to the place I will eventually show you. Take that first step into the unknown, even before you know where the road leads. Because it is good for you to do this.
To venture out without a clear set of instructions. To leave the comfort and safety of home and explore strange new worlds; to seek out new life and new civilizations; to boldly go where no man has gone before!
All of this, of course, within the guidelines of Torah and a relationship with Hashem.
But to stay huddled together in our little corners, fearful of the new? This leads back to the Tower of Bavel. This leads to throwing the best of us into a fiery furnace because we are afraid to face the strange and the new.
This is the danger of conformity, the little death of the self. Never becoming what Hashem wanted to show me because I never went.
The valley may be dangerous, but I cannot spend my entire life standing at its entrance.
"Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for You are with me; Your rod and Your staff, they comfort me."
Not every adventure is good. Sometimes leaving can be selfish, and staying can be righteous. I would never advocate running without looking back. The problem is that I don't always know whether the heavenly voice calling me is Hashem or my own yetzer hara. Yet, I fear I have become so used to ignoring that voice that I no longer bother to tell the difference between them.
When Hashem calls to me in the unique way He has directed my life, why do I not heed the call?
And what's funny is that the brave few who dare, armed with the rod that corrects them and the staff that protects them, venture beyond the familiar without abandoning the Torah that guides them. They change the world.
They begin by facing the same shame, guilt, and pressure as everyone else. But the few who push through eventually reach a place where everyone looks back and says, "Oh yeah, that was always a great idea."
And suddenly, it's mainstream.
It's funny the way we are sometimes.
This is what I hear in Rashi's words. Avram could not ever get the good Hashem had prepared for him by remaining where he was. He had lived through the world of the tower and the furnace and needed to go for himself.
I don't know where the road leads. But I know what happens when I refuse to walk. I have seen my little bluebird in his cage. I have watched him get quieter and more still. And I am terrified that one day I will open his door and he will no longer know how to fly.
So please, Hashem, hear this as my prayer.
Grant me the strength to go for myself.
Because it is good for me.